First Department Overturns Conviction; Bronx D.A. Labels Prosecution a Study in “How Not To”

The Law Office of Matthew Galluzzo, PLLC Team

In People v. Ortiz, 2010 NY Slip Op 00387, the First Department overturned a man’s burglary conviction on account of numerous prejudicial trial errors. First, the court noted that prosecuting attorney improperly impeached the defendant by implying that his initial plea of not guilty to certain past convictions followed by a subsequent guilty plea implied that he was dishonest. Of course, most, if not all criminal defendants will initially enter a plea of not guilty, even if they fully intend to take responsibility for their actions, so as to allow both sides to come together with all of the relevant information necessary to make a decision on plea negotiations or decide on going to trial. Thus, the prosecutor’s use of the defendant’s not guilty plea was unfair and unfounded. As put by the court: “This questioning not only tended to draw an improper inference of dishonesty, but also violated the court’s Sandoval ruling, which only permitted elicitation of the existence of defendant’s prior convictions.”

Next, the prosecutor introduced a mugshot photograph of the defendant’s girlfriend and asked the defendant about her own criminal record. The Court chastised the government for this guilt-by-association tactic: “This evidence had no purpose but to suggest that defendant was associated with a disreputable person (see People v Cheatham, 158 AD2d 934, 935 [1990]).” Id.

Finally, the prosecutor made improper remarks on summation, including an assertion that the defendant “was waiting for the jury to ‘give him his razor back and let him walk out the door.’” Id.

Thus, it is not surprising that the New York Law Journal quoted a Bronx District Attorney spokesman as stating that “we’ve already used this case as a ‘how not to’ example.”

Client Reviews

I found myself in such a dark place thinking only God could understand and help me through this horrible situation. But Matthew Galluzzo did. And he did so in a very kind, compassionate and respectful manner. Enough said.

Client

Matthew Galluzzo saved the day when the unthinkable happened. Every phone call was returned within minutes. All email correspondences were replied to expeditiously. Matt handled our case as if it was a member of his own family in the courtroom. Despite all the obstacles along the way, Matt's legal...

Kate

In less than an hour of assessing my case, Mr. Galluzzo had a clear direction and evoked a confident demeanor that was infectious. During the course of several court appearances he was always prepared, and took more than a personal interest when errors in court procedure occurred. Mr. Galluzzo...

Client

We hired Matt when my son was arrested on several very serious felony charges. Matt is not only very knowledgeable about the law, he genuinely cares about his clients. He was patient and professional, inside the courtroom and out, in what turned out to be a very long process. He worked closely with...

Client

Get in Touch

  1. 1 Over 20 Years of Experience
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 We Fight for You!
Fill out the contact form or call us at (212) 344-5180 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message